Accounting & Finance Root Cause Analysis
A systematic procedure for investigating the underlying causes of problems, non-conformances, or failures to support effective corrective and preventive action.
Purpose
To identify the true root cause of quality issues rather than addressing symptoms, ensuring that corrective actions are targeted and effective in preventing recurrence.
Scope
Applies to quality problems, non-conformances, customer complaints, safety incidents, process failures, and any other event requiring causal investigation across the organisation.
Prerequisites
- Defined problem statement with supporting data
- Access to relevant process documentation and historical data
- Trained facilitator with root cause analysis experience
- Availability of subject matter experts from affected areas
Built with ASIC regulatory requirements, AML/CTF compliance, Tax Practitioners Board obligations, and APES standards in mind.
Step-by-Step Procedure
Define the Problem
Write a clear, specific problem statement that describes what happened, where, when, and the magnitude of the issue.
- 1.1Gather initial facts about the problem from reports and observations
- 1.2Write the problem statement using factual, objective language
- 1.3Quantify the problem in terms of frequency, cost, or impact
- A well-defined problem is half solved; invest time in getting this right
Assemble the Investigation Team
Bring together individuals with relevant knowledge of the process, service, or system involved in the problem.
- 2.1Identify subject matter experts from the affected process areas
- 2.2Include representatives from quality, operations, and any other relevant function
- 2.3Brief the team on the problem statement and investigation objectives
Collect and Analyse Data
Gather all relevant data, records, and evidence related to the problem. Analyse the data to understand patterns and potential causes.
- 3.1Collect production records, inspection data, and process logs
- 3.2Review historical data for similar occurrences
- 3.3Analyse data to identify trends, patterns, and anomalies
- 3.4Create a timeline of events leading to the problem
Apply Root Cause Analysis Technique
Use one or more structured analysis methods to systematically identify the root cause of the problem.
- 4.1Select the appropriate analysis technique such as five whys, fishbone diagram, or fault tree analysis
- 4.2Facilitate the analysis session with the investigation team
- 4.3Working paper all potential causes and the reasoning chain
- Continue asking why until you reach a cause that can be directly acted upon
Verify the Root Cause
Test and validate the identified root cause against available evidence to confirm it is the true underlying cause.
- 5.1Check whether the proposed root cause explains all observed symptoms
- 5.2Verify with data that the root cause was present when the problem occurred
- 5.3Confirm that removing the root cause would logically prevent recurrence
Working paper Findings and Recommendations
Prepare the root cause analysis report with findings, the verified root cause, and recommended corrective actions.
- 6.1Compile all analysis work, data, and evidence into the report
- 6.2State the verified root cause clearly
- 6.3Recommend corrective actions to eliminate the root cause
Quality Checkpoints
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Expected Outcomes
Percentage of root cause analyses where the corrective action successfully prevents recurrence, validating the root cause was correctly identified.
Average time from problem identification to completed root cause analysis report.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many levels deep should the analysis go?
Continue until you reach a cause that is actionable and within the organisation control. Typically this is three to five levels deep, but complex problems may require more investigation.
Who should lead a root cause analysis?
An experienced facilitator who is trained in root cause analysis techniques should lead the investigation. Ideally, this person is independent of the process where the problem occurred to maintain objectivity.
Which root cause analysis method should I use?
The choice depends on the complexity of the problem. Five whys is suitable for simple, single-cause problems. Fishbone diagrams work well for problems with multiple potential cause categories. Fault tree analysis is suited for complex systems with multiple failure modes.
What if multiple root causes are identified?
Multiple root causes are common for complex problems. Each root cause should be documented and addressed with specific corrective actions. Prioritise based on impact and feasibility.
Want this customised for YOUR business?
We'll tailor every step to your exact operations, tools, and team structure.